Our Membership Flavors of the Month

Every month we dream up two unique flavors, partner with the finest local farms and food artisans, and handcraft pints for Members of our seasonal ice cream of the month club. Membership flavors are limited batch and are only available to Members. Since 2009, we have never repeated a flavor for our Members and are soon delivering #213 and #214 below. Scroll through our past Membership flavors to learn what we're all about. 

  outoftheube intotheblack 

Our Signature 'Screams

Our Signature 'Screams are our most lauded, most "milkmade" of our flavors, as voted by our Members over the past nine years. They include ten flavors that we have on our menu at all times, each with a distinctive flavor profile – from fresh, to fruity, to salty sweet. Each was inspired by our favorite local New York neighborhoods and destinations.

  Amagansett Chinatown CobblerHill' Coconut FineChocolate FineVanilla Fingerlakes Gotham Prospect Rockaway  



Our Seasonal 'Screams for October

Each month, we offer a lineup of new Seasonal ‘Screams that rotate monthly. We strive for constant innovation and take inspiration from everything around us – what's fresh at the greenmarket, events around the city, topical news, even our favorite punk rock songs. We ghouls at MilkMade need no excuse to let the big kid in us loose. So come October 1, we start up the Halloween celebrations and keep the dead (wo)man's party going all month long. Past flavors are here

  monster-mash candy-corn snick-or-treat' cactus-haunted-hayride smashing-pumpkin-stracciatella